I should've known things would be different
You wouldn't listen, I wouldn't call back
I was obsessed, you were the best I never had
What would you call that?
How did fate make a mistake?
Who you gonna blame now?
Pull me into your arms
Kiss me on the hood of your car
If you're not here, I'm not yours
Come on darling, it can't be that hard
(Pull me) into your arms
Kiss me on the hood of your car
If you're not here, I'm not yours
Come on darling, it can't be that hard
I lost control when you lost when you lost your temper
Why does my head hurt? Thinking we'd go back there, I know
I was upset, you were a mess, I never asked
What would you call that?
How did fate make a mistake?
Who you gonna blame now?
Pull me into your arms
Kiss me on the hood of your car
If you're not here, I'm not yours
Come on darling, it can't be that hard
(Pull me) into your arms
Kiss me on the hood of your car
If you're not here, I'm not yours
Come on darling, it can't be that hard
(I shoulda known, I shoulda known)
(I shoulda known back then baby)
In the morning with the blinds down
Said you wouldn't let me down
I bet you wouldn't like me now
You said "It's not the same, it'll never be"
I drive by your house for the memories
But you don't like me now
Pull me into your arms
Kiss me on the hood of your car
If you're not here, I'm not yours
Come on darling, it can't be that hard
(Pull me) into your arms
Kiss me on the hood of your car
If you're not here, I'm not yours
Come on darling, it can't be that hard
(I shoulda known, I shoulda known back then baby)
(I shoulda known)
(I shoulda known, I shoulda known back then baby)