Well, she came as a thief in the night Yeah, that girl stole my heart; took it right out Then she left as she'd come: secret, silent I never saw her again Yeah, she came as a thief in the night Well, that girl stole my heart; took it right out of my chest And what did it take for that thief to steal my heart? Did she know that my whole world would fall apart? Was that her plan from the very start? I think so, I think so, I think so, yeah, I bet it was And what was the use to her of this new prize? Did she prove to herself that she could use those eyes To take advantage of a lonely guy? I think so, I think so, I think so, yeah, I bet she did Yeah, she came as a thief in the night Well, that girl stole my heart; took it right out of my chest