Blew out the candles and made a wish And I hoped it would come true I had a feeling, that I was dreaming When I wished for you Chorus: I wish that you were here I wish you could see my tears And I wish I was on your mind, But if wishes were horses, dreamers would ride Tossed a penny, in the well And I closed my eyes I told no one, what I wished for When I wished that you were mine Chorus: I wish that you were here I wish you could see my tears And I wish you missed me tonight But if wishes were horses, dreamers would ride Made a wish upon a star As the sun went down Like the star I'd be in Heaven If you were with me now Chorus: I wish that you were here I wish you could see my tears And I wish I was on your mind, But if wishes were horses, dreamers would ride