Why did you-
Why did you, did you go?
I'll never know
Oh, girl, I wonder if I'm out of your mind
Are you over me?
It hurts
And I can't describe this feeling inside
I remember the times
When we were never once a moment apart
You were the only one who captured my heart
Where did it go wrong, girl?
Why did you leave in September?
Thinking the summer had gone
Now it's a lonely November
Now that my summer has gone
I'm trying not to think of your smile
But it's always then I'd find
That I'm okay just for a while
I remember the times
When we were never once a moment apart
You were the only one who captured my heart
Where did it go wrong, girl?
(Why?) Why did you leave in September?
Thinking the summer had gone (why did you leave me alone?)
Now it's a lonely November
Now that my summer has gone
Now you'll never know how I feel
I'm here for you
If only you could read my mind
You'll always be mine, mine
You'll never know
Why did you-
Why did you, did you go?
I'll never know
And you'll always be
Someone that I'll remember
Now I know it's time to move on
Now I know
♪
I remember the times
When we were never once a moment apart
You were the only one who captured my heart
Where did it go wrong, girl?
Oh, why did you leave in September?
Thinking the summer had gone (why did you leave me alone?)
'Cause now it's cold in December
Now that my summer has gone (I don't know)
Now you'll never know how I feel
I'm here for you
If only you could read my mind
You'll always be mine, mine
You'll never know
Why did you leave in September?
Why did you, did you, did you go?
You'll never know
I'll never know
You'll never know
Why did you leave in September?
Why did you, did you, did you go?
You'll never know
I'll never know
You'll never know
Why did you leave in September?
Why did you, did you, did you go?
You'll never know
I'll never know
You'll never know