You said to meet by the gym after school before volleyball Your grin poked through the door and we met lips As electric as the kiss was The way you told me no When I leaned in for another thrilled me more There goes nature Pulling me along like a sequencer Right on time Turning me into a teenager Will I always be a teenager, now? Oh, I had a hard time falling asleep that night Then woke up anxious to get to school And exchange some sweet nothin' But when I saw you in the hall Without an explanation You called it off There goes nature Pulling me along like a sequencer Right on time Turning me into a teenager I don't wanna be a teenager, now Four breakups later On the last day of school You pulled me aside And I tried to play it cool You'd watched me all year And you knew Bill was wrong And you wished you had stayed through The end of our song