Tell me again about that guy from New Jersey And how he's a piece of shit and how he's not worthy And I'll tell you all my best compliments and jokes and advice Over FaceTime for hours and hours and hours and hours Why? Can't you see my eyes and see right through my views? You're my muse and I fantasize of you Please, tell me what you think of me, am I pretty or ugly? When you're away, do you think of me the same? I want to fall in love I want to fall in love I want to fall in love Please don't leave me Don't leave me a romantic comedy I've been waiting for someone like Casey Please don't leave me Don't leave me a romantic comedy I've been waiting for someone like Casey Lying in your arms, you make me feel again Guide me like a falling star to let this end Guarding our emotions, I'm losing hold of focus, it's heavy How you notice my smile is fire and iron like you wanted So what's the catch? Will you catch me when I fall? So what's the catch? Will you catch me when I fall? Will you love me all night long? So what's the catch? Will you catch me when I fall? Are we singing the same song? Right in the middle of Rittenhouse, from our first date Carved into a tree J and C (carved into my skin) Carved into a tree J and C Love, Jamie loves Casey so much Jamie loves Casey so much Love, Jamie loves Casey so much I love you so fucking much