It was just four hours ago
You, me and him were all alone
We had settled in after some fun
A time that was second to none
That's when we heard a knock at the door
You got up to see who it was
And I haven't seen you since
Won't you tell me who it was
It was probably him and he was probably begging you to come outside
And once his speech was over and his fake tears had dried
You ran into his arms and said, "Baby, I love you"
And he thought, "She fell for it again." But he said, "I love you too"
I can't believe you fell for it again
It was just a month ago
You and me were spending time alone
We had planned on turning a show on
And watching episodes 'til dawn
You head your cell phone ring
You said, "Hold on." And picked it up
Suddenly, you ran outside
Won't you tell me who it was
It was probably him and he was probably begging you to come outside
And once his speech was over and his fake tears had dried
You ran into his arms and said, "Baby, I love you"
And he thought, "She fell for it again." But he said, "I love you too"
I can't believe you fell for it again
You never say who it is
After you run out of the room
And we have no way of knowing
So we just have to assume
But I think I have a hunch
On who's been taking you from me
So when I heard that knock at the door
I knew exactly who it'd be
It was probably him and he was probably begging you to come outside
And once his speech was over and his fake tears had dried
You ran into his arms and said, "Baby, I love you"
And he thought, "She fell for it again." But he said, "I love you too"
I can't believe you fell for it again