Evelyn I hate to wake you up again It's just that I can't sleep When any part of me thinks that you got doubt on your mind Evelyn I know our love so heaven sent But it's hard to feel angelic when everything I'm tellin' you feels out of line We used to talk so much now we don't say a thing Stuck in silence and I'm so tired, you tryna see what all this means So tell me what it is Won't you please, just tell me what it is 'Cause I know that there's a window to your heart that I'm not seein' through I just gotta find my way in Won't you tell it to me straight, you know I would appreciate Often in the way of all the things we wanna say Know that there's a window to your heart that I'm not seein' through I just gotta find my way in Dear Evelyn You always look so innocent With a brain so academic, why can't I prevent this? You bringin' me down I wanna know what point along the way I started askin' you to put away All of these feelings, that ain't workin', sealin' I say it to you We used to walk around, hangin' on by a thread Stuck in bottom, was hidin' what I knew would set us free Won't you tell me what it is Won't you please, just tell me what it is I know that there's a window to your heart that I'm not seein' through Just gotta find my way in Tell it to me straight, you know I would appreciate Often in the way of all the things we wanna say Know that there's a window to your heart that I'm not seein' through I just gotta find my way in With you Evelyn Oh, oh, oh, oh-woah Oh