Do you remember That cold November night? I held you close Evenings in revelry grow old But your words forever soothe me Is it you that's making this hard? I can't imagine moving on Starlight, star bright The first star you see tonight May not be a star And wishing never gets you that far It's not a matter of who loves who I think we're both agreed That love's not on the cards We're talking chemistry And open-ended conversations I never promised myself to you But I wish you would Starlight, star bright The first star you see tonight May not be a star And wishing never gets you that far Starlight, star bright The first star you see tonight May not be a star And wishing never gets you that far But if it could, you know I would Wish for you, and wish that you'd wish for me too