I'm hanging on by dim-lit street
I'm overthinking every word she said
I'm still wrecked from the night and now you left
I'm playing back every single line
You know love never chooses sides
And if I'm wrong and if you're right
Are we both alone tonight
So
Tell me what was I thinking
When I wasn't thinking at all
Yeah
Tell me what was I doing
When I should've taken that call
I didn't pick up, pick up, pick up
But I know I should've picked up, picked up, picked up
All I had to do was pick up, pick up, pick up
That call that night
I'm sorry that I couldn't love you
I'm sorry that I couldn't love you
I sit still at a traffic light
She's in my mind, but she's out of sight
Everything I do I once did for you
Nothing I say comes out the same
'Cause every word falls after your name
If I'm wrong, can I make it right
Or are you just fine being alone tonight
Tell me what was I thinking
When I wasn't thinking at all
Yeah
Tell me what was I doing
When I should've taken that call
I didn't pick up, pick up, pick up
But I know I should've picked up, picked up, picked up
All I had to do was pick up, pick up, pick up
That call that night
I'm sorry that I couldn't love you
I'm sorry that I couldn't love you
I don't even know what I'd say
If I heard your voice today
I know that I'd pick up
If I saw your name
For all I know I broke your heart
Or maybe I never got that far
But I think you should know
I think you should know
Tell me what was I thinking
When I wasn't thinking at all
Yeah
Tell me what was I doing
When I should've taken that call
I didn't pick up, pick up, pick up
But I know I should've picked up, picked up, picked up
All I had to do was pick up, pick up, pick up
That call that night
I'm sorry that I couldn't love you
The way that you wanted me to
I'm sorry that I couldn't love you
I'm sorry that I couldn't love you