We always seem to get here You and I No one really knows me Like your eyes So baby, what's the problem? I can meet you We can solve 'em I don't know what else to do To change your mind So tell me it's a sin For me to want you to myself We always seem to get here You and I Just me, and no one else Could you get by? Between me and all those boys Am I your favorite toy? Or am I just the one That passed your eye? So tell me it's a sin For me to want you to myself Tell me, tell me Don't tell me, don't tell me Tell me, tell me Don't tell me, don't tell me Tell me once again Like how you tell all of your friends How it's just such a fucking sin For me to want you to myself Tell me it's a sin Tell me how I played the fool again I just want you to myself Just for myself You could tell me once again Tell me so I'm sure not to forget Even when I'm by myself I know I'm not myself