You can shuffle, we can scuffle Or talk 'til night turns day I'm here waiting, anticipating We can dance the night away I guess I didn't know you so well Baby that's why I couldn't tell You were just playing hearts Why couldn't I see it You were just playing hearts And now I believe it After midnight, such a blind side I thought you were all in I guess I didn't know you so well Baby that's why I couldn't tell You were just playing hearts Why couldn't I see it You were just playing hearts And now I believe it Didn't look for love to fall Never meant to fall at all You were just playing hearts You were just playing hearts You were just playing hearts You were just playing hearts You were just playing hearts