Why? We had it good, didn't we? We never should try to change Isn't it strange? We had it too good to be true It seems the right thing to do Bow now in the light day I can see You weren't meant for me And I wasn't right for you We had it good, you and me But we never should have kept hanging on To a dream that was gone We had it too good to be true Too good to be true People say We should try to make it work Just one last drink Our love's on the rocks and it's starting to hurt We had it good, didn't we? We never should try to change Isn't it strange? We had it too good to be true Too good to be true We had it too good to be true Too good, too good to be true Too good, too good, too good, too good, too good to be true Too good, too good to be true Too good, too good Why too good, too good to be true We had it good to be true We had it too good to be true