Well the first time you broke my heart It took me by surprise I thought all those songs 'bout love at first sight Were nothing but a pack of lies But then I kissed you beneath the stars I could have kissed you there for days I said please don't let this end But you just walked away Fool me once, shame on you Fool me twice, shame on me But I still ran back to your arms 'Cause baby, third time's the charm Well the next time you broke my heart I thought maybe you had changed We were older now but still somehow I felt exactly the same I tried hard to be gentle I tried hard to go slow But like a frost in early spring You turned cold, cold, cold Fool me once, shame on you Fool me twice, shame on me But I still ran back to your arms 'Cause baby, third time's the charm This time, oh this time I knew how it would end But this time, oh this time I couldn't wait to start again Fool me once, shame on you Fool me twice, shame on me But I still ran back to your arms 'Cause baby, third time's the charm